Questions about OMNY for the Roosevelt Island Tram festered for over a year. After City Council Member Julie Menin waded in, an angry stalemate between bumbling RIOC and bullying MTA emerged. It’s still there, if more frosty than heated, according to an answer the MTA gave an inquiring resident. Paying mass transit users are being victimized by dueling bureaucratic egos.
by David Stone
The Roosevelt Island Daily News
UPDATE, June 27th, 2023
Looking for hardcore examples of governmental bungling and the perils of patronage dumping? Search no further. It’s here with the ridiculous posturing and hapless management blocking OMNY from the Roosevelt Island Tram… and rewarding MTA bullying with $1 million plus annual windfall.
Read the story below. Nothing much changed after RIOC President/CEO Shelton J. Haynes soured already poor relations between state agencies by showering the MTA with blame for the OMNY absence.
Talk about farting into a windstorm, this didn’t even get that promising. And that day ended with RIOC eating crow, amending accusations that suddenly found the MTA working “tirelessly” to get OMNY installed at the Tram Plazas.
Haynes did not write that. It was dictated from a location other than Roosevelt Island.
That was two years ago, and apparently, “tirelessly” means different things to different people. Just a few weeks ago, under the long shadow of countless promises, Haynes reported that discussions were on track for OMNY readers in the “second quarter of 2023.”
The second quarter ends on Friday, but there have been no further announcements.
End of Update
OMNY for the Roosevelt Island Tram? Not So Fast… or at all
“Please note that the Roosevelt Island Tram is under the jurisdiction of the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation of the State of New York. As such, we are unable to provide an answer to your inquiry.”
That’s the bounce Southtown’s Sylvan Klein got when he asked about OMNY for the Tram. A cold shoulder for sure and, in reality, a double dose because RIOC has refused to comment at all on the issue since revealing, at a 2021 board meeting, that they had no contact with the MTA for over a year at that time.
With Menin demanding that RIOC get OMNY readers for the Tram, a nasty private exchange between RIOC CEO Shelton J. Haynes and MTA representatives exposed a blame game. It ended with RIOC sucking wind, humbly claiming that the MTA was working “tirelessly” on getting OMNY readers installed for the Tram.
But no firm date was set, and the little we know about the battle is from information provided by public officials outside RIOC.
Why isn’t Governor Kathy Hochul helping?
Although Hochul controls both agencies, she is running for reelection and tangled between the authorities bogged down with countless patronage appointments and secret deals.
In terms of Roosevelt Island, her primary activity amounts to shielding incompetents from accountability.
The Players
What is the Metropolitan Transit Authority?
The MTA is responsible for public transportation in metropolitan New York City. It includes the subways, buses, and some of the commuter railroads. The Roosevelt Island Tram is not part of the MTA.
What is Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation?
The Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation (RIOC) is a state-run corporation that manages Roosevelt Island. It is overseen by Governor Kathy Hochul.
What is OMNY?
OMNY is the new electronic fare payment system for the MTA. It allows riders to pay their fares with a contactless credit card or smartphone.
Why doesn’t OMNY work on the Roosevelt Island Tram?
The Roosevelt Island Tram is not part of the MTA, so it is not included in the OMNY system. The Tram is managed by the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation (RIOC), which is overseen by Governor Kathy Hochul.
But the Tram is a 20-year member of the MTA’s MetroCard system and has merged with the buses and trains all along. The crush of interest was brought on by a decision to end MetroCard as soon as OMNY is fully available
Currently, the Tram is the single point in New York City mass transit without OMNY access.
How can I pay for the Roosevelt Island Tram?
Currently, the only way to pay for the Roosevelt Island Tram is with a MetroCard. RIOC has not announced any plans to add OMNY compatibility to the Tram.
Why OMNY for the Roosevelt Island Tram Is a Bigger Issue
Tram riders, today, can’t take advantage of user discounts offered through OMNY, and they can’t transfer for free via OMNY between Tram and MTA resources as they have with EasyPass.
That’s unfair to riders, but the MTA bullying and RIOC cowardice go deeper.
Because inept RIOC staff never demanded an escalation clause in their contract with the MTA nor has any renegotiation addressed the problem, the MTA has raked in millions of unearned dollars that should have gone to Roosevelt Island.
As long ago as 2019, then RIOC President/CEO Susan Rosenthal openly discussed the problem at a board meeting. Simply put, the original contract provided fare-sharing at the then prevailing charge of $2.00/per ride. You swiped your card, and RIOC got $2.00, helping pay for Tram expenses, just as it had with Tram tokens.
But twenty years later, you swipe for $2.75, and RIOC still gets only $2.00. According to official figures, that means – just in the last year – MTA awarded itself over a million dollars that should’ve gone to Roosevelt Island.
And RIOC has done nothing but lamely gripe about it. Hochul hasn’t helped at all.
Think about that the next time RIOC whines about scraping up the stingy $150,000 they contribute to nonprofits through Public Purpose Funds. They willingly give away around ten times that to the MTA – which gobbles it up like a pig at the bureaucratic trough.
Who’s looking out for Roosevelt Islanders? As usual, nobody.
Also from the Roosevelt island daily news
- Queens News and Community Updates Affecting Roosevelt Island ResidentsFor Roosevelt Island residents, Queens news and community updates are both close and relevant. From local incidents to new openings and street safety, see how city events shape our days.
- How Roosevelt Island Reflects New York’s Big Moments This WeekThis week, see how Roosevelt Island reflects New York’s big moments, from citywide sports wins and parades to local voting and youth programs.
- How Roosevelt Island Reflects a City on the MoveDiscover how Roosevelt Island reflects a city on the move, capturing the currents of New York through neighborhood routines, sports celebrations, and community moments.
- Keeping Steady Through City Currents: How Roosevelt Island Residents Stay ConnectedNew York’s shifting news often impacts daily routines on the island. Discover how Roosevelt Island residents stay connected through city changes and local events.
- Neighborhood Notes: Weekly Changes and Community Moments Across Roosevelt Island and BeyondNeighborhood notes on weekly changes and community moments across Roosevelt Island and neighboring areas, including emergency response, community events, new developments, and local reflections.
As the Dust Settles
The way the wind cuts across the river this time of year. The way older buildings hold heat but never quite hold air. I told myself that was why my chest felt tight again on certain mornings. Age, perhaps.
5 COMMENTS