Reuven Blau, THE CITY
When Francesca Khalifa picked up her beloved cat from a Brooklyn veterinary clinic after an emergency visit for stomach issues last fall, she couldn’t understand why he was suddenly limping and a nail on his back paw was ripped apart.
A staffer at VERG, the Bushwick clinic on 4th Avenue, assured her that it was nothing serious, according to Khalifa’s account of the Oct. 3, 2021 visit.
Five days later, Charlie Chaplin, her 13-year-old tuxedo cat, was so sick he had to be euthanized.
A necropsy revealed he’d been suffering from a fast moving kidney cancer that was never diagnosed or properly treated, according to Khalifa, who also contends veterinary staff at the clinic’s after hours emergency room injured his leg during a botched X-ray.
But Khalifa and other pet parents who allege abuse or malpractice by veterinarians are left with few options for recompense.
Under New York State law, animals are treated as property rarely worth more than several hundred dollars, according to lawyers who handle such cases.
“There should be more accountability on the part of vets. It’s not good,” said Karen Copeland, who specializes in veterinary malpractice cases. “They give vets so much latitude. It’s pretty incredible.”
New York is one of only 13 states that categorize pets that way. The other states consider them as at least sentient beings. That gives pets higher legal status than mere possessions and allows owners an ability to seek compensatory damages if they are mistreated.
Even when there is an investigation, veterinarians in New York are also rarely disciplined for faulty care and the probes can drag on for years, an analysis by THE CITY in 2019 found. Multiple readers have since reached out with similar complaints about alleged malpractice and slow moving investigations.
Now, Khalifa and other animal advocates are pushing for a long stalled bill in Albany to add some measure of pet justice. They hope that the people who adopted dogs and cats during the pandemic who have now learned about the current legal setup will finally spur state lawmakers to take action.
Vets in the Fight
The legislation, which would allow for legal damages after “the wrongful injury or death of a companion animal,” dates back at least 20 years -– and the State Senate version excludes veterinarians.
Nevertheless, the measure has always been strenuously opposed by the NYS Veterinary Medical Society, which represents more than 2,000 animal doctors across the state.
The group contends that the legislation would increase costs and make basic pet care available only to wealthy owners.
The organization also points out that veterinarians currently use something commonly referred to as a basic “standard of care” to treat pets. If an owner is unable to afford that level of care veterinarians can lower the costs with alternative treatments or perhaps exclude a few expensive tests.
If the law was changed, veterinarians would always be worried about being sued if they didn’t provide top line care, according to the umbrella group.
“That would lead to a significant portion of animals having to be euthanized,” predicted Tim Atkinson, executive director of the Society. He also noted there’s a shortage of vets and argued that any law changes would exacerbate that problem.
On Tuesday, the group held its annual lobbying day in Albany, pushing state lawmakers to block any changes to the legal status of pets and for a host of other legislative issues.
The VMS also argued against proposed legislation to restrict so-called bark softening surgical procedures and an “antimicrobial” proposal that they say “would inhibit or restrict the ability of veterinarians to properly prescribe antibiotics to their patients.”
Still, some veterinarians support change.
“I’d love it if they were considered sentient animals. I don’t care if my insurance goes up,” said Dr. Natara Loose, who conducted the necropsy on Charlie.
Loose, who practices in Bushwick, said some of her colleagues “charge astronomical prices and are not practicing standard of care.”
That sometimes includes failing to perform X-rays of teeth when doing dentist work, a basic precautionary step, she said.
Justice for Charlie
As for Charlie, Khalifa has filed a complaint against the veterinary practice in Small Claims Court. The case — capped at $5,000 — is scheduled for next month.
Khalifa, an acclaimed concert pianist, has also filed a complaint with the state’s Office of Professional Discipline, which oversees veterinarians, records show. The case is pending.
VERG did not immediately respond to a call and email seeking comment.
When Khalifa adopted Charlie in 2015 he had been in foster care for almost a year and a half. “He was deemed unadoptable,” she recalled, noting he lived on the streets for most of his life.
“He was a very shy cat but a sweetheart with me,” she said.
Before his death, he suffered from kidney disease that required routine medical checkups every three months.
When he suddenly began repeatedly throwing up she brought him to the VERG emergency room on Oct. 1, 2021. The bloodwork showed he had anemia, a lack of healthy red blood cells.
Khalifa says medical staff later discovered he ingested pieces of litter. They released him but three days later he struggled to breathe and Khalifa had him euthanized in her home.
“It’s heartbreaking,” she said about her struggle to get “justice” for him.
“I do strongly believe if we want to better ourselves as a society, we really need to take a hard look at how we treat the vulnerable, the children, the elderly, and animals,” she said. “Because they depend on us. And the way we treat them is appalling.”
THE CITY is an independent, nonprofit news outlet dedicated to hard-hitting reporting that serves the people of New York.
more form the roosevelt island daily news
- What Are The Different Types of Oak Trees?There are many different types of oak trees, and they can be found all over the world. Each type of oak has unique features, and they all provide different benefits to the ecosystem. by David Stone A Roosevelt Island Daily News Feature The most common types of oak trees: White Oak: White oak is one
- A look at the work derisively called “hippie physics”In the late 1960s and early 1970s, several physicists became interested in the ideas of eastern mysticism, particularly those of the Indian guru Maharishi Mahesh Yogi. These physicists, including some of the most respected names in the field, began exploring the possibility that quantum mechanics could be used to explain various paranormal phenomena. by David
- LIFT THE SUPREME COURT’S VEIL OF SECRECYThese nine individuals make decisions that affect every American. Why should they get to do it secretly? By Jim Hightower | May 18, 2022 A Roosevelt Island Daily News Feature When Supreme Court member Sam Alito’s secret plan for canceling the constitutional right of people to end their pregnancies leaked to the public, Republican politicos went ballistic.
- TUCKER CARLSON’S ‘GREAT REPLACEMENT’ THEORY COMES FROM AN ANTI-AMERICAN NAZIWhy has the American far right adopted an anti-American conspiracy theory as its rallying cry? By Juan Cole | May 18, 2022 The Roosevelt Island Daily News Before a hate-filled 18-year-old murdered 10 and wounded 3 African Americans in Buffalo on May 14, he penned a rambling screed about replacement theory. The most common version of this whiny
- Hemp bill sails through New York SenateSteve Bittenbender | The Center Square contributor May 18th, 2022 The Roosevelt Island Daily News (The Center Square) – A bill that calls for New York to promote additional uses for the hemp grown in the state sailed through the state Senate on Tuesday and will now go to Democratic Gov. Kathy Hochul. The Senate voted