A prolonged mess over the handling of PPF grants was finally resolved, last week, and approved by RIOC’s board. That, as well as future handling, needed the aid of Markus Sztejnberg, who was described as “our special counsel” by chief counsel Gretchen Robinson.
By David Stone
The Roosevelt Island Daily News
Untangling the PPF Grants Mess
Unfortunately, we’re unable to report any details on how RIOC’s special counsel fixed an unnecessary conflict between its alleged community relations team and nonprofits dependent on PPF grants. That’s because acting board chair Linda Manley, without offering a reason, declared the board in executive session.
The committee then discussed the grant issues over Zoom while the public was shut out. That’s a violation of state law because no reason was given. The law does not allow executive sessions just because the board feels like it. At that, the meeting may have violated its own enabling legislation because it does not have the mandatory five resident members.
Note: Because of Governor Cuomo policies, now honored by Governor Hochul, this meeting took place with nonresident members inn the majority. Of eleven participants in the discussion, only two live on Roosevelt Island.
The state agency innovated through the pandemic, keeping a full staff on payroll, working or not. But when it came to the nonprofits, they hammered them for changes made in the same vein.
Creating a free food pantry, being denied funds
For example Roosevelt Island Disabled Association president Wendy Hersh explained, “Unfortunately, due to the COVID 19 pandemic, RIDA was unable to offer the services and events that were planned due to social distancing and sheltering at home. But, due to the food insecurity that we recognized on Roosevelt Island, we stepped up to the plate and offered food distribution and then a food pantry to Roosevelt Island Residents…”
Hersh’s organization was denied 50% of their funding by RIOC’s community relations team.
The community relations team is lead by Erica Spencer-EL who did not attend the board meeting.
Markus Sztejnberg, who bills himself as a special counsel on ethics, seems to have been called in to untangle the mess. But the mess is at least several years old. Inexplicable grant increases and decreases followed an apparent path of reward and punishment. Little logic interfered. And each year brought howls of protest, then fixes.
The issue, this year, is different as RIOC withheld funds for months without explaining. When push came to shove, penalties for the nonprofits finding their way through the pandemic appeared.
Now, There’s Also a Fix for the Future
After the board emerged from the questionable executive session, it quickly approved releasing the funding withheld from four desperate nonprofits. The session was long and whatever Sztejnberg did in fixing it remained secret. But that and a follow up plan effectively fixed the PPF grants debacle and paved the way for a smoother ride ahead.
Neither before nor after the executive session did Sztejnberg speak, but Robinson gave him full credit for sorting the internal mess out.
As for the future, the board approved a plan for turning PPF grant administration over to the New York Community Trust (NYCT). This effectively removes the activity from the community relations team, turning it over to a firm known for its granting integrity. It’s unknown territory for both RIOC and its nonprofits but better than the painful screw ups of recent years.
The award to NYCT covers three years at $25K per. They will decide how $150,000 in PPF grants are best awarded.
One it-could-only-happen-with-RIOC moment, though, shaded the decision.
But first an anecdote…
Both my dentist and I had fathers who were accountants. We recently shared related jokes. Forget about mine because his was much better. Here’s how it goes…
A human resources manager interviews three accounting job seekers, using one key question: “What does 2 plus 2 equal?”
First candidate answered, “4, of course.”
When candidate number two said, “Five…?” he as also eliminated.
“Whatever you want it to equal,” the savvy and successful third accounting candidate said.
Back to the PPF grant plan…
That joke came to me after RIOC CFO John O’Reilly answered a question from board member David Kraut.
“Can we afford it?” Kraut wanted to know about the $25,000 award.
O’Reilly volunteered that he’d given “Erica” a report showing how it actually saved money. That, he explained, was because it wiped out the cost of RIOC ‘s own handling. On the surface, that kinda makes sense, but it’s really just a candidate number three answer.
Unless RIOC reduces its staff – no laughing allowed – there are no savings. There’s just less work for a bloated staff now hiding behind frosted glass and locked second floor offices with the shades always drawn.
More from the Roosevelt Island Daily
- Happy Holiday Gifts for Cat Lovers and Friends
Best Choice Gifts for Cat Lovers Gifts for cat lovers from handmade artist Deborah Julian bring you a wide choice of cards and artwork that will delight and stay. High quality Famous Artists’ Cats Card - The View, Roosevelt Island’s Secret Front Yard in AutumnRoosevelt Island’s secret front yard wasn’t built for hiding, but history made it that way. As a result, it’s easy to miss as it slopes toward the East River. By David Stone The Roosevelt Island
- “Miracle on Main Street,” RIVAA Holiday Group Show Opens SaturdayIn a holiday tradition, on Saturday, December 4th, the Roosevelt Island Visual Art Association, opens Miracle on Main Street. Everyone is invited to meet the artists and appreciate their work at a free public reception
- Fulfilling a community’s worst fears, the Southpoint “renovation” is now completeIs the now finished Southpoint “renovation” an example of tasteless bureaucrats run amuck or something worse? Redeeming virtues are few, and a walk through repeatedly brings up the question: Why? By David Stone The Roosevelt
- Good news now: The reindeer herd at the Tram Plaza has not been culled…As we reported earlier, RIOC’s holiday decorating team planned on culling the reindeer herd in the Tram Plaza, from five to four. But in reality, they went the other way. There are now six “healthier”
