The High Line’s Ruined: Now Who Committed This Crime?

The High Line’s Ruined: Now Who Committed This Crime?

Did we ruin the High Line? The answer’s different for tourists, real estate developers and anyone who actually once loved this mess. But ruined it is.

By David Stone

for The Roosevelt Island Daily News

My love for the High Line started early in my New York years.

It’s 1990, and I’m working in Manhattan but still living in New Jersey.

Driving down 9th Avenue on my way to the Holland Tunnel, I see this elevated railroad crossing every street all the way to 14th. What’s really striking, it branches off into upper floors in buildings along the way.

Built to ease dangers along 10th “Death” Avenue, the elevated West Side Line served for only 20 years, beginning in 1933.

And there it sat, a large historic treasure collecting weeds, trash and rust, 40 years after it was abandoned.

In the early 2000s, I got a closer look when sales calls sent me deep into Chelsea, where Martha Stewart relocated. I thought it was an economy move like the many art galleries nearby.

Even at distance, the misfit of weedy, intrusive architecture is evident.

But maybe it hinted at the area’s feature as a real estate cash cow.

High Line Park Takes Shape

Fending off Rudy Giuliani’s attempt to tear it down and turn the land over to developers, a devoted group of admirers with a vision saved the High Line.

That vision became real in 2009.

Taking advantage of the High Line’s location, above the street, through blocks left much as they were in the mid-20th Century, planners landscaped a trail.

That trail led through history but kept a refreshing distance above the nearby urban congestion and noise.

Hard to believe, this is the High Line in 2009, ten years before its ruin.
Wild flowers then caught plenty of sun.

But danger already lurked as ugly, inappropriate buildings began blocking views — and sun.

Architecture only a mother — or profiteering real estate developer — could love intrudes in 2019.

A rare, genuine urban trail without traffic hazards, the early High Line Park was a leisurely stroll through the far West Side. 20th and even 19th Century buildings remained.

Gradually, they ruined the High Line…

Views into Midtown made that district stand out as it must have, a goal for folks mired in Hell’s Kitchen.

But there was distinctly New York fun too.

New, inspired architecture had its place, without jamming into the park, without a “Look ma, no hands!” showoff appeal.

SPONSORED: Travels with George: New York, A Cat’s Eye View by David Stone and Deborah Julian

Along the High Line, Chelsea played urban theatre.

Even though we returned for walks along the High Line over the years, the abrupt outburst of ugly buildings still surprised.

Gradually, they ruined the High Line, changing it from a detached urban trail into an artificial canyon flanked by up close, intrusive structures detracting from the landscape.

Ugly buildings.

It’s like they’re inventing ugly on the fly, just for the High Line.

A traumatic social decline followed.

Walking the High Line now, often clogged with tourists, you’re likely to be passed by millennials in a hurry. Their conversations are gossipy, but do they even know where they are?

And who cares what your “I’m like…” pseudo personality did during the latest workplace drama? Why force it on the rest of us?

And why do businessmen pick the High Line for deconstructing the latest deal?

A ruined High Line is not New York…

The most disconcerting fact about the old railroad today is its un-New York character. Well, not quite. It is the New York of real estate developers.


The High Line’s gone, and it ain’t coming back. Greed scars a once promising venue where we saw and felt the city differently. Now, it’s a canyon, a pedestrian shortcut between the Whitney and Hudson Yards.

No need to wait for stop signs. The real estate developers didn’t.

More from Assorted Ideas, Large & Small

  • When Was the Smallpox Epidemic in America? End of the Trail
    Here on Roosevelt Island in New York City, the Smallpox Hospital, a historic ruin, is an icon. It’s lit at night and stands out like a ghost to anyone passing along the East River. Its main section was designed by legendary architect James Renwick. But trailing out behind this decaying structure is a story that
  • Update: Tram Shutdown Today. Without Warning, RIOC Does It Again
    Unchastened by a similar failure in June, RIOC again announces a Tram shutdown without any advance warning. Perhaps they were too busy thanking themselves for the 4th of July. Their belated advisory arrived last evening at 8:34 p.m. 7-6-2022 Update: Below find out what else they forgot to tell you. by David Stone The Roosevelt
  • Unmitigated Gall: RIOC Thanks Itself for the 4th of July
    In an act of unmitigated gall, RIOC thanked itself for the 4th of July celebration after blocking residents from using Southpoint, the public park they pay for. The tweet embraces the “planning committee,” consisting of Altheria Jackson, Mary Cunneen, Kevin Brown, Anthony Amoroso and Wanda Coleman. Roosevelt Islanders are never mentioned. by David Stone The
  • Walking and Biking to the Office May Be Good for New Yorkers. It’s Not So Great for the MTA.
    Prior to the pandemic, Avi Ashman would travel daily by train from his home on the Upper West Side to his job in Midtown, among the riders who combined to take close to 5.5 million trips in the subway each weekday in 2019. Jose Martinez and Suhail Bhat, The City Republished by The Roosevelt Island
  • Smart Planning Means a Happy, Peaceful 4th of July
    The 4th of July, 2022, on Roosevelt Island was as peaceful — pre-fireworks — as it was sunny and warm. Advance planning paid off with previous years’ problems never developing. by David Stone The Roosevelt Island Daily News Kids of all ages anticipate the rockets red glare to come after nightfall, but for most, the

Written by:

2,354 Posts

View All Posts
Follow Me :

Leave a Reply

2 thoughts on “The High Line’s Ruined: Now Who Committed This Crime?

You May Have Missed

%d bloggers like this: