dog and cat on the floor
Photo by Marián Šicko on

The eternal question: cats or dogs? Which is better?


People have been debating the merits of dogs vs. cats for centuries, and the answer is still not clear.

Dogs are known for their loyalty and intelligence, while cats are celebrated for their independence and cuteness. But which one is better, cats or dogs? That’s a question that has yet to be answered.

by David Stone

A Roosevelt Island Daily News Feature

Nuts and Bolts, Dogs or Cats?

orange tabby cat beside fawn short coated puppy
Photo by Snapwire on

Scientific research has been conducted on the matter of dogs vs. cats intelligence-wise, but the results are inconclusive. Dogs and cats have unique strengths and weaknesses.

See also: Some People Can’t Handle Animal Consciousness. Why?

So it depends on your preferences and your take on the consensus.

If you want an animal that will be your devoted friend and companion, then a dog is probably the better choice. If you’re looking for an independent pet that doesn’t require as much attention, then a cat might be a better option.

Cats, though, I can say with conviction from my own and others shared experiences are much funnier. Whether their clownish behavior is intentional or they’re just naturally goofy, that’s only debate.

On the other hand, dogs love you no matter what. It’s even been said that Hitler’s dog loved him. That’s a rare trait and beyond value.

But ultimately, the decision of whether to get a dog or a cat is up to you. Both make great pets, and it comes down to personal preference. But many, like me, believe you can’t get it wrong, either way.

So which will you choose – dogs or cats? Here is a Q&A to help you along.

You’ve Got Questions. We’ve Got Answers

What are the key differences between dogs and cats?

Cats and dogs are popular pets that offer domestic companionship. However, there are some key differences between these two animals.

For one thing, cats are generally more independent than dogs, having never developed pack behavior. They don’t need to be taken on walks because they easily adapt to a litter box. And they’re content to spend most of their time sleeping or grooming themselves.

Dogs, on the other hand, are much more reliant on their owners for attention and exercise. They need regular walks, and they love playing fetch or going for a swim.


In terms of personality, cats are often seen as aloof and independent, while dogs are typically seen as loyal and playful.

Finally, cats usually live indoors, while dogs typically live outdoors. This means that cats require less space than dogs and are better suited for smaller homes.

Dogs are social animals that crave companionship. Another difference is that cats are natural hunters, while dogs were bred to work alongside humans. This means that cats are often more aloof and self-sufficient than dogs, which can make them better pets for busy people.

Cats don’t mind time spent alone as dogs do, but there are exceptions. And both sometimes feel sad or lonely and show it.

Also, cats require more stimulation and exercise than dogs. But, at the end of the day, both cats and dogs make loyal and loving companions.

How do people tend to lean when it comes to dogs vs. cats?

People tend to be either dog people or cat people, although plenty, like me, love and are fascinated by both.

Dog people are typically outgoing and social. They like to be around people and they’re usually pretty active. They’re also loyal and protective.

Cat people are usually more independent and introverted. They’re often content to spend time by themselves and they don’t need as much attention as dog people do.

They can also be quite independent and aloof. So, when it comes to cats vs. dogs, there are two different types of people. Which one are you?

What scientific research is on dogs vs. cats intelligence-wise?

There has been a long-standing debate on which species is smarter, cats or dogs. A caution, though, too often not considered is that smart for a dog or cat is not the same as smart for a human. We use a faulty measuring stick.

Anyway, some people are dog people, and some are cat people, but there is scientific research to back up which animal is smarter.

Studies show that cats have more neurons in their cerebral cortex than dogs. This region of the brain is responsible for problem-solving, memory, and information processing. A cat has approximately 250 million neurons while a dog has approximately 160 million.

The number of neurons an animal has does not necessarily mean they are more intelligent, but it does show that cats have the potential to be smarter than dogs. It’s an evolutionary development.

Maybe dogs have fewer brain cells because they do fine with what they have. Why waste energy on something your species doesn’t need?

Dogs, on the other hand, excel in social intelligence. They evolved to be good at reading human emotions and working with humans as a team. They are better at understanding language and following commands than cats.

From my experience, I’ve concluded that cats fail to follow commands largely because they don’t feel like it. And unlike dogs, cats don’t agree with the idea that people are their bosses. That’s my take, anyway.

In conclusion, cats are probably smarter than dogs when it comes to problem-solving, but dogs are better when it comes to socializing and working with humans.

Which makes better pets – dogs or cats?

Pets provide companionship, love and support – everything we need to get through the tough times. But when it comes to cats and dogs, which make better pets? The answer may surprise you.

Unlike dogs, cats are relatively low-maintenance. They don’t need to be taken for walks, and they can happily entertain themselves for hours with a simple scratching post or a box of toys. Cats also tend to be cleaner than dogs, spending much of their time grooming themselves.

However, cats can be aloof and independent, which some people find off-putting. Dogs, on the other hand, are known for their boundless enthusiasm and loyalty. They quickly become part of the family, and they’re always eager to please their owners.

But dogs also require more attention than cats – they need to be exercised regularly, and they tend to make messes around the house.

In the end, it’s up to each individual to decide which type of pet is right for them. But an increasing number of people pick both, finding that cats and dogs often live happily together.

(Warning: a trial run for compatibility is essential before making any decision like that.

Which animal causes more allergies – dogs or cats?

For generations, cats and dogs have been beloved pets in households across the world. But for some people, these furry friends can cause more than just a little sneezing.

Pet allergies are one of the most common types of allergies, affecting millions of people each year. But when it comes to cats and dogs, which type of animal is more likely to cause an allergic reaction?

Interestingly, studies have shown that cats are responsible for more allergies than dogs. Cat allergies are two to three times more common than dog allergies. There are a few theories as to why this is the case.

One possibility is that cats produce more of the protein that causes allergies, known as Fel d 1. Another theory is that cats groom themselves more often than dogs, which spreads the allergen-containing saliva around their fur and into the air.

Whatever the reason, those with pet allergies should take care to avoid contact with both cats and dogs to avoid an allergic reaction. For those with a severe allergy, even a small amount of exposure can trigger symptoms like watery eyes, difficulty breathing, and hives.

So if you’re looking for a low-allergy pet, you may want to consider a fish or reptile instead.

Are dogs or cats better around children?

It’s an age-old debate: cats or dogs? When it comes to children, there are pros and cons to both.

Dogs are called “man’s best friend” for a reason – they’re typically loyal, supportive, and loving animals. They can provide companionship and security, and can even be trained to perform tricks or tasks.

But they also require a lot of care and attention, and their size can sometimes be overwhelming for small children.

Cats, on the other hand, are more independent and don’t need as much hands-on care. They’re usually more low-key than dogs, and their small size means they’re less likely to accidentally injure a child.

However, cats can be temperamental, and their claws can pose a danger if they’re not properly trimmed.

Ultimately, there’s no right or wrong answer when it comes to cats or dogs and kids – it’s a matter of personal preference.

How much exercise do dogs vs. cats need?

Cats and dogs have very different exercise needs. Dogs, for instance, require far more exercise than cats.

A typical dog needs at least 30 minutes of moderate to vigorous exercise every day, while a cat only needs a few minutes of playtime.

This difference is due in part to the fact that cats are generally much less active than dogs. They tend to spend most of their time lounging around, sleeping, and grooming themselves, while dogs are usually eager to play and explore their surroundings.

As a result, cats don’t require as much exercise to maintain their health and fitness. But both cats and dogs benefit from having an active lifestyle, so it’s important to find ways to incorporate some physical activity into your pet’s daily routine.

wood love animal dog
Photo by cottonbro on

The first cats I had as an adult, Julia and Dylan, seemed cooped up, so my girlfriend and I bought leashes and took them for walks around our Buffalo city block. The smells, sights and sounds stimulated them, and our neighbors were equally fascinated. None had ever seen cats on leashes.

Sometimes, I think cats’ reputation for laziness more fairly reflects a lack of opportunity. I’ve never had a cat that sleeps sixteen hours a day as the books say.

And with Julia, the best part of the walk was the last couple of blocks where, with a little coaxing, she’d break out into a sprint with me racing to keep up. Finally, she run right up our front steps. She knew where home was. She’d wait patiently by the door while I caught my breath.

What personality traits can you expect from dogs vs. cats?

Cats and dogs, given the opportunity to interact freely, will show the full range of emotions and behaviors. Cats, though, since they’ve never absorbed the pressure to conform as dogs do, are more eccentric.

My cat Max, for example, will climb on my lap, looking with a needy plea for attention or loving reassurance. But he will, with just as much conviction, walk away the instant he gets another idea. No clingy lingering.

Dogs, on the other hand, once they feel like they’re part of the family, will be your most loyal friend. Dogs are even known to sense trouble, like strokes or seizures, far enough in advance to bark out warnings.

Bottom line: Dogs are more loving, and cats are more entertaining.

So dogs or cats – which one is better?

There’s no clear answer when it comes to cats or dogs – both have unique advantages.

Cats are typically lower maintenance, and they don’t need to be taken on long walks multiple times every day. Instead, cats usually get all the exercise they need from running and climbing around your home.

However, dogs can provide a level of companionship and emotional support that cats simply can’t match. Dogs are also generally better at following commands and learning tricks, which can come in handy if you ever need your pet to do something specific.

But it always comes down to personal preference – some people prefer the independent nature of cats, while others find the loyalty and obedience of dogs more appealing.

There’s no wrong answer – it’s just a matter of finding the pet that’s right for you. Often, if you pay close attention, they will tell you, beguiling you into picking them from any others.

More from Assorted Ideas, Large & Small

1 Comment

Leave a Reply

Previous Story

Kicking Off Pride Month, NYS Parks Commissioner Erik Kulleseid at FDR Four Freedoms Park

Next Story

MTA Still Looking for Light at End of Staffing Shortage Tunnel

Latest from Assorted Ideas

0 $0.00
%d bloggers like this: