“When will RIOC’s war on our island trees stop?” she wrote. That was September, 2018, but “Just this week we lost an old maple behind the church,” another resident wrote. On December 17th, 2021.
By David Stone
The Roosevelt Island Daily News
A Yearslong RIOC War on Trees
“I’ve been observing the mass destruction of our island’s trees for the last 16 years,” the 2018 observer continued. “I was hoping RIOC would start repairing the devastation they created. But no! It is just getting worse.”
Provoking that comment was the chopping down of two old growth trees, clearing them permanently from the Rivercross Lawn. The fresh gap allowed a blast of sunlight where shade once protected picnickers and made the place suddenly foreign. Its heart cut out.
“I always loved that tree and wanted to paint it but I took him for granted….I never had enough time and I said it will be there for ever….,” wrote RIVAA artist Georgette Sinclair.
“The 2 trees that they chopped were older and different than the ones surrounding the green space… they had their dignity of old and were enchanting us with their beauty …. they were not aligned with the others…. is that why they killed it? Sorry I feel so strong about it, but I love nature and it hurts to see how we destroy it.”
The RIOC war on trees, sadly, neither began nor ended there.
A Little History for the Record
Back in the 1990s, drivers entering Roosevelt Island saw a “Tree City USA” sign. The community was proud of its commitment to nature and greenspace. There was an active tree group documenting every tree from north to south.
Some remember a beautifully graceful grove of willows on the east side of Lighthouse Park. In summer, runners and strollers swept a curtain of soft branches aside, passing others idling in the shade. Now, only one remains, although willows have gender and need company for new growth.
As we know, new growth runs against the grain of RIOC’s war on trees.
What went wrong?
It was inevitable. Unchecked, unaccountable management by uninvested outsiders will go wrong, all the time. And as the years pass, the losses multiply. The war on trees became fueled by RIOC’s strange lust for tourists and a suburban shopping mall esthetics they think is just right for Roosevelt Island.
In 2020, it was the long row of inkberry trees that shaded the otherwise overheated promenade south of the Meditation Steps. RIOC’s deep thinkers decided they must be chopped to near oblivion. The reason…? They blocked views of the river, RIOC said.
But the ravaging of the inkberry row was soon forgotten because, days later, RIOC began destroying the last two stretches of natural shoreline on Roosevelt Island.
Revetment of the shorelines was necessary for repairing and strengthening against future storm damage. We all knew that, but a non-intrusive plan that included saving the wild growth strips along the borders was in place. RIOC scraped it, though, after investing a million dollars in development. They now refuse to say why they bought, instead, into a vastly more expensive – and ugly – Langan plan. Langan, also for unknown reasons, is RIOC’s preferred contractor – for everything.
In 2021, RIOC hit the high point in its war against trees: The Shelton J. Haynes/Langan Roosevelt Island Rock Garden.
The Shelton J. Haynes/Langan Southpoint Rock Garden is so hideous that ,when Governor Kathy Hochul issued a press release about its wonders, she used twilight photos with colored filters.
Governor Kathy Hochul’s view of Southpoint
In her calling-in-all-the-troops-to-shout-“Hurrah!” press release, Hochul desperately wants you to look at the sunset, not the hideous Shelton J. Haynes/Langan Roosevelt Island Rock Garden.
What We Learn From the RIOC War on Trees
There’s a long history here, and now, with the full backing of Governor Andrew Cuomo-In-A-Dress, momentum is in RIOC’s favor, the community’s only hope is that trees are a finite presence. Eventually, they’ll have chopped them all down.
Even the tourists for whom RIOC lusts might see the light.
More from the Roosevelt Island Daily
- MTA Launches Six-Year Signal and Track Overhaul on A and C Subway LinesThe MTA launches a six-year signal and track overhaul on A and C subway lines, bringing CBTC and major infrastructure upgrades to the Fulton and Liberty Avenue corridors through 2032.
- Long Island City Rent Overcharge Lawsuit Seeks $50 Million Against DeveloperA Long Island City rent overcharge lawsuit seeks about $50 million from Rockrose Development, raising questions about billing practices, tenant protections, and legal oversight in NYC’s fast-changing rental market.
- Astoria E-Scooter Rider Dies After Northern Boulevard Crash in Long Island CityA 22-year-old Astoria e-scooter rider died after a Northern Boulevard crash in Long Island City. Details remain under investigation, highlighting micromobility risks on busy city streets.
- Hate Crime Charges Filed After Vandalism at Fresh Meadows Kosher Bagel ShopHate crime charges have been filed after vandalism at a kosher bagel shop in Fresh Meadows, with prosecutors alleging bias-motivated acts. Hearings are set in New York’s legal process.
- Midtown Subway Shooting Leaves 26-Year-Old Dead; Queens Incidents SeparateA shooting inside a Manhattan subway station left a 26-year-old dead. Police investigate the Midtown incident and separate shootings in Queens as commuters seek safety.
Stack Work Advances While Answers Do Not
On June 17 and 18, HPD told the first meeting of the Roosevelt Island Steam Plant Demolition Community Advisory Group that smokestack demolition had no projected start date. Residents and the CAG would receive at least five business days’ advance notice once a date was set. Scaffolding around the stacks could not proceed until soil removal and backfill were complete and the area stabilized.
A tree outside the RI Community Garden on Main St (near FDNY operations) has recently been completely cut down too. Unsure of the reasoning and all that remains now is a tree stump and pile of logs.
The beat goes on, Justin. There is no interface with the community, and I think the underlying cause is, sadly, that they are overstaffed with nothing else to do.