Roosevelt Island’s little known gay history jumped out of the figurative closet, in 2019, at Joe’s Pub. It’s a musical. The Gorgeous Nothings In Concert.
By David Stone
We learned something in 2019, when a theatre company, Life Jacket, brightly exposed Roosevelt Island’s gay history.
No, it didn’t start with Four Freedoms Park’s giant Ascend With Pride flag, that June.

Gay history spins all the way back to the 1930s with men imprisoned on Roosevelt Island for “lewd and unnatural acts which offend the public decency” (New York Penal Law 722, Section 690).”
That inspired The Gorgeous Nothings, gayly reviewed in Broadway World.
The workshop performance, based on extensive research, looks forward to a broader audience. Credit goes to the Roosevelt Island Historical Society for a major dose of archival resources.
But, in truth, Roosevelt Island Gay History is not exactly right. Back in the 1930s, it was Welfare Island but still the same slab of schist jutting out of the East River.
And it took place in a penitentiary, not Southpoint or Four Freedoms Parks, which occupy the space now.
The Fag Follies: Roosevelt Island Gay History
Welfare Island is where New York City once sent its undesirables. The prison later relocated to Rikers, but in the 1930s, smallpox victims, the insane, the poor and gays shipped up the river.
Funny thing is, the enlightened souls of 1930s New York thought homosexuality contagious. Some Republicans still do.
To avoid contamination, the city fathers segregated the population.
And according to Bobby Patrick’s review, they “did what gays do and made something beautiful out of the worst possible circumstance.”
At Christmas, the Fag Follies sang out the bawdiest works of Noel Coward, Irving Berlin and Lorenz Hart.
How about Nobody Loves A Fairy or Taint Nobody’s Business If I Do?
You won’t hear them anywhere else. Read the whole story and keep up with its development.
Roosevelt Island’s growing gay history has deep roots.
More from Assorted Ideas, Large & Small
- Haynes, Other Execs Cleared in the “Open Letter” InvestigationIn March 2022, a confidential source handed The Daily an envelope containing an “Open Letter” composed by a group calling itself “We Deserve Better New York.” Frustration and anger spilled off its pages, but the … Read more
- What’s the Latest on the Secret AVAC Failures?“The west side of the AVAC line is obstructed impacting garbage collection via vacuum along the duct work servicing building complex at Westview and BLG 531 (Rivercross),” a RIOC Advisory said. It foreshadowed worse to … Read more
- Dumpster Dive: What’s in NYC’s Trash Now — and What’s NotNew Yorkers are throwing away less, but recycling less too, according to new city data. Samantha Maldonado, The City This article was originally published on Sep 20 5:00am EDT by THE CITY The Department of … Read more
- 5 Ways Manufacturing Companies Can Cut ExpensesFinding ways to maximize efficiency and minimize costs is a crucial part of helping a business thrive. Discover ways manufacturing companies can cut expenses.
- How long has this been going on? The Gaping RIOC Leadership GapA leadership gap at RIOC, with roughly 150 employees, has been evident since mid-summer and has gone unaddressed publicly. That the situation was only marginally better before kept it from seeming the congealed muddle it … Read more
To the best of my knowledge, I was the first openly gay member of RIRA in 2000…
True as far as I know, but that was only the start of your breaking new ground. It’s amazing how much more open society is since then. Not that long ago, in my lifetime, Liberace sued a journalist for writing that he was guy. Amazingly, he won, although he was gayer than a spring breeze. That’s how hidden everyone had to be. Sunlight’s good for the country.
[…] Related: Roosevelt Island’s Gay History […]
[…] Related: Roosevelt Island Gay History […]
[…] Is Roosevelt Island Exposed? Gay History And Fabulous Tales […]