RI DAILY

Manhattan's little, quieter island and beyond

Daily beats from a quieter Manhattan.

RI DAILY

Manhattan's little, quieter island and beyond

Reporting Roosevelt Island since sunrise.

Red Buses Are Better, Not Great. The Worst Goes Unaddressed

RIOC's Red Buses may be improving, but the high-risk behavior of passengers goes unaddressed. Strollers block aisles, tourists occupy reserved seats, and disabled passengers are at risk. RIOC's neglect puts safety and fairness at stake. The management's failure to act poses a danger, especially for those with disabilities. It's time for RIOC to confront these issues.

Roosevelt Island News
RIOC Red Bus at Tram Stop

While RIOC has gotten more buses fixed up and running on Main Street, long waiting gaps continue. Worse though is the mind-boggling, high risk behavior that goes on, unaddressed, day after day.

by David Stone

The Roosevelt Island Daily News

RIOC Communications Director Bryant Daniels offered an optimistic Red Bus report at a CB8 online meetup. But the complaints started at 10:35 the next morning.

“Could not get on southbound bus just now because driver wouldn’t/couldn’t ask/tell stroller users and others to move back from front.”

As far back as 2019, Transportation Director Cy Opperman and the COO Shelton Haynes confronted angry protests over strollers clogging up Red Buses.

The frustrated resident followed up. “The same driver, at 11:05, southbound at 10 River Road — didn’t seem too upset with my little tirade about what happened at 10:35.  One of the passengers who got on with me thought I was more annoyed with the driver — which I was — but I explained to them, ‘It’s some of the passengers who don’t think vs some of the passengers who are thoughtless.'”

By 6:15 that evening, we got this: “Been waiting 15 minutes for the bus and the app says it was here 3 minutes ago…” The Red Bus finally arrived at 6:24. “I waited 26 minutes at rush hour. At subway now and too crowded for people to get in. Driver is screaming he’s not moving until people get away from the doors.”

The aisle was clogged with two open strollers.

The Unaddressed Danger

The high risk danger everyone in authority ignores.

I shot the photo above a couple of weeks ago because it illustrates the extreme conditions Red Bus riders endure. At first glance, it’s sorta benign, but look again.

A man with a walker can’t board past the Red Bus driver. A stroller is anchored square in the middle of the aisle. The impassive mom has blocked access to all four reserved seats on the right side. Across the aisle, a chatty clan of tourists occupies all four reserved seats.

What’s Wrong With This Picture?

Unaddressed…

  • The physically challenged man with the walker is at high risk. He could be slammed into the dashboard or window with any sudden stop. How much more in liability claims and insurance can this carelessness cost us?
  • Tourists are given no insight into what’s expected, especially those who are not English-speaking. You’d hope they’d be more thoughtful, but then, you’d have to be as oblivious to tourist behavior as RIOC is.
  • Strollers, instead of being a convenience, have become a menace on Red Buses. Moms, dads, and other caregivers demand preference over everyone else. They clog the aisles with impunity, often taking up multiple seats reserved for others.
  • The RIOC driver takes zero responsibility for high risks on his bus, let alone the ignoring of common courtesy. This is rampant with RIOC. It’s on the Tram. It’s everywhere.
PSD Tram Assistance Sign
While this poster at the Tram elevator appears helpful, it’s crude and cynical. There are no PSD officers anywhere. Although RIOC management knows this, they refuse to take it down. They apparently prefer looking like they’re doing something when they are not.

Finally…

As RIOC struggles with keeping Red Buses running on Main Street, failures will occur. It’s inevitable with its aging fleet. They should be handled with more grace as residents, especially on the north end, suffer. Advisories would help, but most often, hopeful riders manage in the dark.

Even at that, the unaddressed issues of strollers denying everyone else fair access is profoundly unkind and probably illegal. People with disabilities are supposed to have equal access. RIOC honors that right only for tourists. It allows unfettered selfishness.

Worse yet, it risks health and safety everyday. RIOC has a Public Safety Department, but where is it? These hazards are obvious. Enforcement should be too.

The Emergency Was Always Underground
Featured

The Emergency Was Always Underground

How decades of documented risk were ignored while a convenient emergency took center stage.

The steam plant and the steam tunnel were never two problems. They were one system. They were only separated later, when separating them made development easier and responsibility harder to pin down.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Roosevelt Island, New York, Daily News

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading