Some unexpected RIOC financial revelations spilled out of a recent Audit Committee meeting covering next year’s budget. OMNY and the Tram were top of the list.
By David Stone
The Roosevelt Island Daily News
RIOC Financial Revelations, OMNY and the Tram

As reported, last week, frustrations over the absence of OMNY at Roosevelt Island Tram turnstiles are growing. With all MTA turnstiles and buses having OMNY touch pads for payment by the end of last year, the Tram’s a MetroCard only orphan.
The reasons, now exposed, make it worse than you think
OMNY expands payment options for riders on mass transit and eases transfers. But although a contract with the MTA is in place, the Tram got left out of the mix. RIOC financial revelations expose how internal malfunction helped create the problem for riders, but they also reveal a significant and ongoing loss of revenue.
As RIOC CFO John O’Reilly explained it, RIOC’s stuck on an agreement signed a decade ago that brought MetroCard to the Tram. A triumph at the time, it made transfers with subways and buses simple and added shared revenues benefiting RIOC.
But there’s a problem former president/CEO Susan Rosenthal discussed at a board meeting in the past. That is, the contract includes no automatic escalation clause. And because fares rose several times since, RIOC’s gotten shorted, receiving only the original amount.
In fact, the MTA gets $2.75 every time anyone swipes a MetroCard to get on the Tram, but RIOC still gets only the original $2.00. It’s sister state agency keeps the rest.
Malfunction Beyond Belief
Although the shortfall was known by RIOC management since the first fare increase, nothing got done about it, but recent mistakes reach even deeper. While blaming the lack of OMNY for a budget shortfall, O’Reilly said that RIOC has not been in contact with the MTA since before the pandemic.
That’s right. While sacrificing $.75 every Tram ride, RIOC failed to act for over a year and a half as OMNY reached everywhere else in the system.
Earlier this month, however, RIOC president/CEO Shelton J. Haynes told a resident, “Roosevelt Island is on the list to get OMNY. Unfortunately, we are going to get those upgrades until next year.”
While Haynes mistakenly omitted a “not,” his claim is clear but apparently untrue. Out of touch hardly explains it.
As of this date, OMNY status is as up in the air as a Tram cabin, and thanks to a hopelessly un-inquisitive board, no discussion of how the screw up happened or who was at fault ensued… as RIOC held steadfast in its role as the state agency that has never made a mistake.
Also from the Roosevelt Island Daily
- Weed Retailers Rail Against ‘Financial Slavery’ in State Cannabis RolloutGabriel Poblete and Rosalind Adams, The City This article was originally published on Jun 7 4:18pm EDT by THE CITY State officials in charge of New York’s slow-to-start retail cannabis rollout met with license-holders Tuesday
- Mayor Eric Adams’ Sister-In-Law Landed $150,000 City Government GigYoav Gonen, The City This article was originally published on Jun 8 5:01am EDT by THE CITY The administration of Eric Adams appointed the mayor’s sister-in-law Sharon Adams to a job at the city Department
- How to Stay Safe as Hazardous Wildfire Smoke Engulfs New YorkSamantha Maldonado and Rachel Holliday Smith, The City This article was originally published on Jun 7 3:04pm EDT by THE CITY Smoke from wildfires in Canada brought another day of especially bad air quality in
- RIOC Sucks Wind Now In Defamation Claims Against WhistleblowersWhistleblowers Erica Spencer-EL, Amy Smith and Jessica Cerone sued RIOC for unlawful termination in February. In an extraordinary move, the state agency fired back with defamation claims in a separate lawsuit. But last month, The
- Why Blue Lights Are Appearing at Some Subway StationsJose Martinez, The City This article was originally published on Jun 7 5:00am EDT by THE CITY Three subway stations that are among the most prone to people going onto the tracks are the first
[…] cannot get free transfers and that RIOC misses out on substantial revenue. RIOC is fully aware, and President/CEO Shelton J. Haynes admits no contact with the MTA for over a year while the rest of the system […]
[…] board simply stands by…for ten full years. And the state agency that never made a mistake has talked about it publicly for over two years while doing […]