Amid construction under a hot sun, discarded, a local treasure suffers the abuses of neglect. Rejecting creative suggestions for reuse, RIOC leaves historic Tram cabins open to graffiti or worse.
By David Stone
The Roosevelt Island Daily News
“This abandonment is from 2009. So, lots of folks to blame,” remarked one longtime resident after seeing the damage. But while that’s true, the current state of utter neglect and indifference to our history is jarring.
“Shameful and disgusting,” another said. The legacy and hard work of historian Judith Berdy and others simultaneously trashed.
When the rebuilt Tram went into operation in 2009, the administration thoughtfully stored the old cabins and gears in a fenced off area outside the Motorgate Atrium.
Surely, someone would come up with an idea for preserving this local treasure.
A local treasure collects dust…
It wasn’t for lack of ideas.
Probably the most robust came from the imagination of architect Tad Sudol. Sudol then led the Roosevelt Island Visual Art Association which helps RIOC organize public art installations.
Sudol designed a Motorgate Atrium come alive with the colorful gears offsetting its austere poured concrete.
And in 2016, RIOC paid over a million bucks for a redesign of Southpoint Park by Fitzgerald and Halliday. Approved by its board in January 2017, the plan included the cabins as a welcome center. RIOC has never adequately explained why that plan was scrapped in favor of a vastly more expensive deal with longtime partner Langan.
Others were simpler. A refurbished cabin might welcome visitors in Motorgate Plaza.
But none were adopted, leading to a local treasure left open for abuse.
As work progressed on Motorgate, the protective fencing came down, peeled away, leaving the cabins open to graffiti and subject to damage by construction crews.
Another piece of Roosevelt Island’s legacy bites the dust, a local treasure left in the care of RIOC.
More News from the Roosevelt Island Daily
- Roosevelt Island Weekly Recap: Community Life, Local News, and Everyday ConnectionsOur Roosevelt Island weekly recap covers local news, community events, and the threads of daily life connecting neighbors on and off the island.
- Queens News Highlights and Roosevelt Island Community ConnectionsExplore the week’s Queens news highlights and Roosevelt Island community connections, from public safety to housing, historic places, and local events.
- How Queens News Shapes Life on Roosevelt Island This WeekExplore how Queens news shapes life on Roosevelt Island, from major fire responses to local court cases and housing initiatives, reflecting the rhythms and routines of our shared city life.
- Queens Community Updates: Transit Projects, Public Safety, and Neighborhood EffortsQueens community updates including transit projects, public safety developments, and neighborhood efforts, with special relevance for Roosevelt Island residents.
- How Roosevelt Island Responds to Change and Challenge Across the East RiverExplore how Roosevelt Island responds to change and challenge across the East River, reflecting on community adaptation, safety, transit, civic life, and neighborhood rhythms.
The Five Amendments That Sold Out Roosevelt Island
Roosevelt Island did not lose control of its southern waterfront in a single deal. It happened in five quiet steps. Five amendments. Five missed chances to renegotiate.
