Do ugly benches now forecast a sad future for Southpoint Park?

Do ugly benches now forecast a sad future for Southpoint Park?

Ugly benches were not what Jim Bates had in mind when he made a simple request… If RIOC had to redesign Southpoint, he asked for seating comfortable for visitors with physical limitations.

By David Stone

The Roosevelt Island Daily News

President of the Roosevelt Island Disabled Association, Jim Bates was as busy as he was dapper, driving his electric scooter around town. When asked about adding his wisdom and insight to a committee forming to evaluate Southpoint, he agreed.

Formed for assuring a community based plan, the committee worked alongside a professional team with a goal of enacting local preferences.

He passed away a couple of years later, but the Fitzgerald & Halliday redesign plan carried his mark.

Strangely, though, just eighteen months after RIOC’s board of enablers approved the FHI plan, they blew it away in favor of a much more expensive and contrary plan.

The when and why of that is unknown, but we’ll have more on it later.

But for now, about the ugly benches…

Here’s what Jim Bates didn’t like…

Not only are the park’s current benches uncomfortable for many, absent arms or rails, they are difficult for others needing aid while sitting or rising. Jim Bates wanted that changed.

Instead, we got…

“Ugly benches” may not be an adequate description.

By what twisted judgment does anyone think paying for inadequate crap like this is an improvement?

When I was a kid in woodshop class, Mr. DiSapio taught us how to make domestic objects out of wood. As a teenager, I sawed, sanded, polished and wired a table lamp inspired by a water pump.

Although my dad kept it in service for the rest of his life, I could always see where my clumsy figures failed at matching the art of the idea.

But one thing I know now, my woodwork was better than what’s being forced on us in Southpoint.

And one more thing pisses me off. My dad was physically disabled by polio and lived most of his life before the idea of barrier free designs emerged.

My dad could not use the junk being bolted down in Southpoint.

And I can imagine my casual friend Jim Bates rolling his eyes.

A long bench might as well have a sign: Disabled Keep Out

But here’s the worst of it — they ain’t done yet, and the rest of the park is shaping up as ugly as these benches.

More from the Roosevelt Island Daily News

  • Julie Menin takes the helm of the New York City Council’s Committee on Small Business
    The Roosevelt Island Daily News “I ran for City Council on a platform to help support our struggling small businesses with a detailed plan of action focused on reducing onerous fines, implementing legacy small business legislation, reducing the commercial rent tax and creating a one stop portal for licenses and permits,” Menin said in a
  • Nobody beats the Wiz, but fortunately Roosevelt Island did…
    Nobody beats the Wiz? What’s that got to do with Roosevelt Island? Nothing now, and that’s the good news. Here’s why… by David Stone The Roosevelt Island Daily News Carhartt Men’s Knit Cuffed Beanie Here’s how it looked in 2000 – when RIOC agreed to let Nobody beats the Wiz founder Stephen S. Jemal build
  • Robert K. Hughes, After 35 Years, Ends His Service on Roosevelt Island
    Rob Hughes started work on Roosevelt Island in 1982 as a hospital care investigator at Goldwater Hospital, now the site of Cornell Tech. He leaves as Coler-Goldwater’s executive director after nearly 13 years in the post. by David Stone The Roosevelt Island Daily News Hughes service on Roosevelt Island was interrupted in 1997 when he
  • Slow Job Growth Reflects Omicron’s Economic Toll
    Greg David, THE CITY This article was originally publishedon Jan 20 at 7:55pm ESTby THE CITY/Sign up here to get the latest stories from THE CITY delivered to you each morning. Even with the city filled with tourists and office workers coming back to their desks, New York gained only 26,000 jobs in December, a pace that would put
  • Who killed the Tram Plaza Reindeer?
    Property destruction comes in all flavors, but some land in a whole new category of stupid – like what happened to the Tram Plaza Reindeer… by David Stone The Roosevelt Island Daily News More from the Roosevelt Island Daily davidstone1313 See author's posts
Share

Written by:

812 Posts

View All Posts
Follow Me :

Leave a Reply

One thought on “Do ugly benches now forecast a sad future for Southpoint Park?

%d bloggers like this: