In an op-ed in the New York Times, “Tasmanian Tiger Is Extinct. Why Do People Keep Seeing Them,” the so-called experts strike again. Scientists engage their inner know-it-all, and mass media helps them along.
Estimated reading time: 2 minutes
By David Stone
“The Tasmanian tiger is still extinct. Reports of its enduring survival are greatly exaggerated,” writes columnist Asher Elbein.
But as is the privilege afforded “experts,” he is not asked for proof.
Neil Waters, president of group believing otherwise, “promised conclusive photographic proof of a surviving thylacine (Tasmanian tiger). Four photos, he claims, show a family, including a juvenile, moving through dense brush.”
Here’s what he says, along with the photos…
The so-called experts strike again…
In the Times article, the so-called experts struck again, serving up evidence of previously mistaken sightings of other extinct creatures. One, Darren Naish, even tags the sightings as “a social phenomenon, not a zoological one,”
Yet, not once is the Coelacanth, a prehistoric fish thought to have died out with the dinosaurs, mentioned. But 6.5 million years later, a fisherman caught one. Nor were 9 others once declared extinct but later found alive.
This is typical of the Times and other mainstream media, conservative to the core, poisoners of imagination. In lopsided analysis, they’ll show you why you’re a loon.
“We all make mistakes: even the most experienced naturalists make misidentifications, sometimes hilarious ones,” Naish adds, for example.
We don’t know whether Waters is right, and neither does the New York Times,. But that doesn’t stop them from letting the so-called experts strike again, using ridicule as their weapon.
The article implies that researchers like Waters are so invested, they see what’s not there. But the writer does not acknowledged that established experts cling to similar belief systems, capable of equivalent misperceptions.
More from Assorted Ideas, Large & Small
- A Week Rooted in Community: Daily Life and Neighbor Connections on Roosevelt IslandThis week, daily life and neighbor connections on Roosevelt Island come into focus with stories of parks, transit, public safety, and community rhythms shaping the summer.
- NYC Health + Hospitals Data Breach Lawsuit: What Roosevelt Island Readers Should KnowA proposed class action says millions of NYC Health + Hospitals patients, staff and family members may have had deeply sensitive information exposed. Here is what Roosevelt Island readers should know.
- Queens Community News and Events: How Local Stories Echo on Roosevelt IslandQueens community news and events shape daily life on Roosevelt Island and beyond. From park reopening and fundraisers to public safety and local transit, catch up on the stories echoing across both neighborhoods.
- How Roosevelt Island Connects with Queens This Week: Community, Safety, and Neighborhood CelebrationsHow Roosevelt Island connects with Queens is clear in this week’s stories of community, public safety, celebrations, and neighborhood life in both boroughs.
- Connecting Roosevelt Island Community Life with Local Transit, Safety, and Business InitiativesConnecting Roosevelt Island community life with local transit, safety, and business initiatives, this week’s Beat explores how citywide stories shape our days and routines.
The Line That Didn’t Land
I stood in the back of Good Shepherd Chapel on the evening of April 15, 2026, at the Steam Plant Demolition Town Hall, watching people adjust scarves and jackets before the meeting began. Benjamin Jones, President and CEO of RIOC, thanked us for attending and, without a pause, said he was “pleased to host tonight’s town hall on the city’s demolition of its steam plant.” The demolition, in other words, was not up for discussion.
