After being “flooded with complaints” about faulty and delayed results at COVID testing sites, City Council Member Julie Menin introduced legislation requiring the city to track problems called in on the 311 help line. Menin includes Roosevelt Island in her district.
by David Stone
The Roosevelt Island Daily News
Accountability for COVID Test Sites

Menin says her office has been “flooded with complaints from constituents that have gone to pop-up COVID test sites that promised several day test results and have never received their results, received them after several weeks or received incorrect test results.”
In one egregious case, she sent “a cease and desist letter to one such operator, PacGenomics, and referred that matter to the NY Attorney General’s Office who took action against the company.”
With not well-known pop-ups on what seems every street corner, Menin grew concerned after hearing so many complaints. Then, she got annoyed.
“I don’t know what happens.”
Wanting insight on how the City handles complaints, Menin assigned a staff member to call 311 and see how things were handled.
- On the first attempt, a 311 operator referred the staff member to a telephone number with the New York City Department Of Health and Mental Hygiene.
- On the second attempt, a staff member was referred to the New York State Department of Health. When the Operator was asked what would happen if we called them, the 311 operator replied “I don’t know what happens.” When the staff member was passed through to the NYS Department of Health, the agency had an automated message stating that “all complaints must be submitted in writing.”
- ·On the third attempt, the 311 operator stated the staff member should call either Equifax, Experian, and Transunion and gave their phone numbers. The staff member asked if the city was noting complaints about these testing sites, and the operator did ask for information about the name of the testing site and said they would forward it to the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene.
In short, she found that the city was all over the place and collected almost no data at all.
COVID Test Site Accountability Legislation
Menin’s proposed new law would required the city to “create and track COVID-19 testing site complaints on their 311 website and mobile app. DoITT (NYC’s IT Department) would also be required to maintain a public website that updates daily on the number and nature of complaints received for each testing site, the agency each complaint was referred to, and the disposition of each complaint.”
Accountability starts with identifying the problem, then gathering real numbers on its impact.
More from the Roosevelt Island Daily News
- When Was the Smallpox Epidemic in America? End of the TrailHere on Roosevelt Island in New York City, the Smallpox Hospital, a historic ruin, is an icon. It’s lit at night and stands out like a ghost to anyone passing along the East River. Its
- Update: Tram Shutdown Today. Without Warning, RIOC Does It AgainUnchastened by a similar failure in June, RIOC again announces a Tram shutdown without any advance warning. Perhaps they were too busy thanking themselves for the 4th of July. Their belated advisory arrived last evening
- Unmitigated Gall: RIOC Thanks Itself for the 4th of JulyIn an act of unmitigated gall, RIOC thanked itself for the 4th of July celebration after blocking residents from using Southpoint, the public park they pay for. The tweet embraces the “planning committee,” consisting of
- Walking and Biking to the Office May Be Good for New Yorkers. It’s Not So Great for the MTA.Prior to the pandemic, Avi Ashman would travel daily by train from his home on the Upper West Side to his job in Midtown, among the riders who combined to take close to 5.5 million
- Smart Planning Means a Happy, Peaceful 4th of JulyThe 4th of July, 2022, on Roosevelt Island was as peaceful — pre-fireworks — as it was sunny and warm. Advance planning paid off with previous years’ problems never developing. by David Stone The Roosevelt
One thought on “Julie Menin wants accountability for COVID test sites”