February 1st, 2020, Foodtown’s Grand Opening announcement answered the long held wishes of Roosevelt Island residents. The much criticized Gristedes supermarket, along with the reviled John Catsimatidis, were out. The truth differed from the appearance, but that went mostly unnoticed.
by David Stone
The Roosevelt Island Daily News

The Foodtown Grand Opening Meant Gristedes Was Gone – Or Did It?
Distaste for the Roosevelt Island Gristedes ran so deep that the supermarket made a Reddit list of New York City stores people said they would never use a second time. One woman made her decision not to move to Roosevelt Island after visiting the only supermarket. Another wondered why every Gristedes smelled like cat food.
In the New York Times, an editorial, commenting on Catsimatidis’s bid for mayor, said he couldn’t be trusted for cleaning up New York until he figured out how to clean up his stores.
But local criticism was worse. Roosevelt Islanders complained for decades about stale meats, stock on shelves far past sell by dates and marked prices suddenly higher when you reached the checkout. All that would be gone now, and it was – except for Catsimatidis.
Was Foodtown really a game-changer?
Most Roosevelt Islanders were so thrilled over seeing Gristedes gone, they didn’t notice that Foodtown had not been a grocery chain for years. Foodtown was a branding operation, and the name change was part of a makeover.
Gristedes’s owner, the Red Apple Group, never left, but to their credit, they swept out the bad, replacing it with the new. For all day-to-day purposes, the Foodtown grand opening converted a Gristedes into a D’Agostino market. Red Apple had successfully done similar switches during the previous year.
Although the D’Agostino name never came up, the much admired New York City chain was a core element in bring Roosevelt Island the quality market residents deserved. D’Agostino managers worked closely with Red Apple, and positive results remain in place.
My favorite memory…
As the grand opening date approached, a D’Agostino representative told me that Catsimatidis planned on attending, showing his support. In a nanosecond, I advised against that. Roosevelt Islanders were thrilled at seeing him gone, not eager for his endorsement for change. That act had gotten a little old by now.
More from the Roosevelt Island Daily
- Join Roosevelt Island Library Events, Nov. 16 to 28Roosevelt Island Library events from Monday, Nov. 16, through Saturday, Nov. 28, include English conversation hours, intermediate We Speak NYC classes, a book discussion, a crochet club, a winter gear giveaway, and a film screening.
- Fall for Arts Murals Remain on Display Before Motorgate MoveThe Fall for Arts murals are still on display on Meditation Lawn as of mid-November, the Daily found. In the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation’s October newsletter, RIOC President and CEO B.J. Jones wrote that the murals would remain standing for…
- Sunday’s PSD blotter: an assault call at 400 Main, four medical calls at 546 MainSunday’s PSD blotter lists 20 incidents: an assault call at 400 Main Street, four aided calls at 546 Main, five non-criminal investigations and a vehicle accident on River Road.
- NYC Specialized High School Test Disrupted by Technical Problems, Students Await New DatesThe NYC specialized high school test was disrupted by technical problems. Affected SHSAT students will be rescheduled automatically, but new dates remain unannounced.
- Weekly public safety blotter: alarm calls cluster at 546 MainNov. 8-14 public safety blotter: 102 entries, down from 112. 546 Main Street logged 22, including five smoke or alarm calls. Medical calls and transports fell.
The Contractor RIOC Wasn’t Allowed to Remember
Professor Lydia W. Tang recognized the name LiRo-Hill. During the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation’s September 10, 2026 board meeting, Chief Operating Officer Mary C. Cunneen presented eleven construction management firms recommended for contracts lasting up to six years.











Same company different name. Check your credit card and it says Gristedes. Over priced store. Much more than Whole Foods or Trader Joe’s.
The change at the time, just before the pandemic hit in 2020, was in who was managing the store. Foodtown is a franchise, not a manager. Red Apple (Gristedes) brought in managers from D’Agostinos to clean things up. It was much better at first, then, after a year or so, the old Red Apple crowd took over again. It’s gone downhill since.
Thanks for your comment.