It was September 11th, 2021, the twentieth anniversary of an American tragedy. Across the nation, in countless ceremonies, people joined together in respect and remembrance. But not on Roosevelt Island, where competing parties staged a pair of divisive spectacles.
By David Stone
The Roosevelt Island Daily News
Early Saturday morning, a ceremony co-sponsored by RIOC and the Roosevelt Island Residents Association (RIRA) drew a crowd of sixty, split roughly in half between residents and state employees.
Somber and simple, the first September 11th event inexplicably sought successfully to exclude residents. In a string of duplicate emails and social media posting, they blamed the Delta coronavirus variant. But it was strange because, as competing ceremony organizer Matthew Katz complained, RIOC showed no such restraint toward other recent events.
RIOC, Cool and Perfunctory. And embarrassingly brief…
The state agency, for example, inspired larger, maskless events like the Hope Memorial opening and their outdoor movies, in recent weeks.
RIOC failed to address the contradictions, but it wasn’t the only gaff.
“A full schedule of the tribute will be made available this week,” they promised repeatedly in email blasts and social media. But they never kept that promise.
And weirdly, at the end of every email, they added, “We look forward to your participation in this poignant tribute.”
After discouraging exactly that.
The Daily learned that RIOC initially planned a larger, public event, but opted for this stripped down event after plans for a concert in Four Freedoms Park fell through. In the end, it was more like a RIOC photo op than any sort of tribute to the fallen on September 11th.
Starting on time at 8:30, Haynes, then Brown, who read the names of locals lost twenty years ago, spoke. But when they finished, it was only 8:40, six minutes shy of the announced nationwide moments of silence. At 8:46 a.m. on 9/11/2001, the first plane struck the World Trade Center.
Unprepared with anything to fill the gap, Brown shrugged and asked for two minutes of silence anyway. Well ahead of the rest of the country. The disrespect was mind-boggling, even from RIOC.
September 11th, 2021, Part Two
“Our event, which is centered on community members’ remembrances, not flags and wreaths, will take place at the Memorial, conceived and built by RIRA 20 years ago…”
That snarky comment from Matthew Katz, quoted by the Roosevelt Islander, signalled dissatisfaction with an email from Haynes.
“I thought it might be appropriate if the two organizations (RIRA and RIOC) combined forces this year to offer the community something approaching our earlier efforts to honor the residents and special ops firemen that we lost.”
It was unclear why Katz, who served as RIRA President on September 11th, 2001, tried speaking for the group in 2021.
Haynes answered. “RIOC will acknowledge this important day, commemorating those lost, by lowering all flags at half-staff and participate in the nationwide moment of silence at 8:46 AM, led by Chief Brown and our PSD department.”
It did not appear, at that point, that Haynes planned on attending in person, but he did.
Haynes’s response sparked a heated response from Katz, announcing a competing event. No more than a couple dozen residents attended.
One Community, Divided
By the time RIOC’s cool and Katz’s frustrations closed out a disappointing September 11th, 2021, for Roosevelt Island, absences discolored the day.
First of all, over 11,000 Roosevelt Islanders were denied a viable local gathering. Divisions were obvious but made more so by the absences.
At neither event did NYPD or FDNY make an appearance. Small crowds huddled together, but children never played a role. RIOC’s perfunctory exercise failed to include more than a single board member, and only a minority of its well-paid executives attended.
Were any elected officials even invited?
And if Katz really wanted a community event, why contact RIOC so late, well after plans were in place? And under what conditions did he assume Residents Association leadership?
RIOC’s divisiveness and isolation always plays a role, one that leaves the community out. But splintering the community from within earns special notice.
By the time, September 11th, 2022, rolls around, our best hope is for new leadership and less self-promotion. It takes special gall to turn this day inside out and make it all about those of us still here, not the victims of that extraordinary violence.
More from the Roosevelt Island Daily
- Queens Subway and Far Rockaway Stabbings Spur Police InvestigationsQueens subway and Far Rockaway stabbings on September 30 prompted separate police investigations and community response after two fatal incidents disrupted daily routines.
- Fatal Stabbing on J Train at Woodhaven Boulevard Spurs Subway Safety Concerns in QueensA fatal stabbing on J train at Woodhaven Boulevard raises fresh subway safety concerns in Queens, as NYPD investigates and riders reflect on recent incidents.
- J and M Train Weekend Service Changes: What Riders Need to KnowJ and M train weekend service changes will impact riders for five weekends as crews replace elevated track switches. Here’s what to expect and how to prepare for modified schedules across Brooklyn and Queens.
- Coastal Flooding Disrupts Southeast Queens Streets and TransitCoastal flooding disrupted streets and transit across Southeast Queens as a fall nor’easter brought heavy rain and renewed calls for resilience and improved drainage.
- Nor’easter Brings Slow Streets and Transit Delays Across Queens and NYCAfter the nor’easter, slow streets and transit delays across Queens and NYC greeted commuters. Utility crews continued repairs as normal routines resumed Monday.
Before the Door Closed
The May 14 RIOC board meeting began with public concern over the steam plant and ended with two votes that revealed more than any report could. Some meetings announce themselves by what is said. This one announced itself by what the room permitted to move and what it stopped before it could breathe.
1 COMMENTS