Former president/CEO Susan Rosenthal’s big win in the discovery part of her lawsuit against RIOC sent the board scrambling into emergency session. That came just five days after a lazy decision to skip another monthly board meeting.
By David Stone
About Susan Rosenthal’s big win…
As we first reported in October, last year, Rosenthal’s lawsuit contesting her firing clobbered both the state agency’s board and Governor Andrew Cuomo. It seized on a major political blunder by Cuomo.
If the state wanted to get rid of her, as an “at will” employee, they could have at any time. No reason necessary because those terms came with the job. Instead, the governor’s office chose trashing her in a racially charged attack. On Juneteenth, a day celebrating the end of slavery, after a ridiculously rushed investigation that turned a minor disgruntled employee’s gripe on a time into something far uglier and more graphic.
The apparent dunderheaded act also opened her firing up to a challenge for wrongful dismissal. Rosenthal has charged RIOC and the state with racism and the board with failing to perform its legal duties.
Violating its own rules, the governor’s team, lead by chief lieutenant Richard Azzopardi, fired her with a brutal press release exclusive to the New York Post. State investigations into similar misconduct are supposedly secret. But as New Yorkers have seen, time and again, there are two sets of rules in Albany.
This one followed the governor’s rules.
After failing at finding substance in a disgruntled employee’s complaints, an Albany based team, turning on a dime, coughed up a whole new set. These were much worse, and Azzopardi paraded them in the Post.
The new charges arose like magic, accusing Rosenthal of sexual misconduct never before reported. Based on their extensive nature, their sudden appearance clanged like an out of tune bell.
They rested on a series of telephone only interviews and secret tapes that allegedly evidence the charges.
But there was no written report, no notes on the interviews and no copies of the tapes. It was a sort of “trust me” case.
Rosenthal said, “No,” and demanded evidence of everything used against her. The state, under Attorney General Letitia James, and the board argued vociferously in opposition.
Strangely, after invading Rosenthal’s privacy with career wrecking public accusations, the state argued that the employees they say attacked her should have theirs protected.
What she won…
Rosenthal’s big win was extensive. Justice Arthur F. Engoron agreed with her entirely, and here’s what he ordered the state and RIOC to surrender:
- Copies of all recordings of Petitioner;
- Notes of any interviews with persons complaining about Petitioner;
- Drafts of the June 19, 2020 press release, and any communications relating to such press release;
- Communications concerning the decision to terminate Petitioner;
- Communications, including but not limited to emails, memos and status reports, from Petitioner or other RIOC employees, to government officials, concerning or referring to the steam tunnel on Roosevelt Island, and any documents reflecting the government’s reaction to those communications; and
- Communications, including but not limited to emails, memos and status reports, from Petitioner or other RIOC employees, to government officials, concerning or referring to the public health and safety hazards regarding the steam tunnel on Roosevelt Island, including but not limited to the reports from the United States Army Corps of Engineers and Langan Engineering and Environmental Services, Inc., and any documents reflecting the government’s reaction to those communications.
Although the owner of the secret tapes is undisclosed so far, a number of RIOC employees’ participation in the will be exposed, assuming these terms are met.
They are: president/CEO Shelton J. Haynes; chief counsel Gretchen Robinson; project manager Prince Shah; assistant counsel Arthur Eliav; human resources director Tajuna Sharpe; and clerical worker and original complainant Karline Jean.
Others may be involved, but these are the names contained in the lawsuit so far.
He gave the state and RIOC until June 11th for producing the documents, sending a panicked board into emergency session.
What happens next after Rosenthal’s big win?
Last night, RIOC’s board met in emergency session, discussing “Pending Litigation.” It was not open to the public.
Since RIOC’s board has barely enough spine to sit upright in chairs, it’s unlikely any decisions were made by them. Albany, the star chamber getting them into this mess in the first place, is certainly pulling all the strings. And the board will, of course, unanimously vote in favor or whatever Albany gives them.
While they can appeal on various grounds, drawing the case out, a settlement avoiding discovery is more likely.
It’s unknown what Rosenthal might settle for, but the damages to her reputation, the crude invasion of her privacy and loss of pension are substantial. What is known is that the community, through the RIOC tax, will end up footing the bills.
In either case, while Rosenthal may or may not get the evidence she’s requested, we are unlikely to ever see much, if any, of it. Even disclosed, it will probably be sealed from public view.
We will keep you posted on this as well as the other troubles roiling RIOC.
More from the Roosevelt Island Daily
- Management Fail: Hot Dog Wars Force Summer DramaHot dog wars broiled all summer in the Roosevelt Island Tram Plaza, thanks to poor judgment and absenteeism in RIOC’s management ranks. Because the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation is deeply bunkered, blocking public engagement, knowing who the genius was who decided to jam a hot dog cart into an area reduced by construction isn’t possible.
- Plan Ahead: No F Train Service Into Manhattan This WeekendStarting tonight – Friday, August 12th – F Train Service into Manhattan from Roosevelt Island ends for the weekend. F Trains will be rerouted along the E Line, starting at 9:45 p.m., until 5:00 a.m. on Monday. This presents some problems, but here are a few easy enough work arounds. by David Stone The Roosevelt
- FDR Four Freedoms State Park, Cool Green Oasis in a Hot CityThe long, hot days of summer can be a brutal experience in the city. The concrete and asphalt reflect the heat back up at you, and the dry air seems to suck all the moisture out of your skin. But just across the river, there’s a cool green oasis waiting for you. by David Stone
- Roosevelt Islander Deborah Julian in PWP Members Show in LICOpening with a free public reception on Thursday, PWP – Professional Women Photographers – hosts MY NYC at Matted, gallery space at 46-36 Vernon Blvd in Long Island City. Among those exhibiting is Roosevelt Islander Deborah Julian. Her pictures have previously been selected for juried exhibits across the U.S. and in Great Britain. by David
- Hey, Governor Hochul! Where the Hell Are Your RIOC Managers?Judged by recent observations, RIOC managers are rare birds never seen anymore outside captivity. Start with bunkered, elusive CEO Shelton Haynes… No, start at the top. New York Governor Kathy Hochul has not caught the scent of RIOC’s mounting failures under her direction. Her hypocritical evasion of leadership echoes on down the pike and piles