RI DAILY

Manhattan's little, quieter island and beyond

Stories that matter, from the heart of the East River.

RI DAILY

Manhattan's little, quieter island and beyond

Reporting Roosevelt Island since sunrise.

Are some species – humans for example – better than others?

One thing has always bugged me about science. (It’s not the only thing.) It’s the idea of “superiority” that pervades reporting. It’s as if every species everywhere must measure up to human capabilities. by David Stone Imagine trying to compare...

Assorted Ideas
ethnic eccentric male stylist dancing in creative room

One thing has always bugged me about science. (It’s not the only thing.) It’s the idea of “superiority” that pervades reporting. It’s as if every species everywhere must measure up to human capabilities.

by David Stone

Imagine trying to compare a dolphin to a squirrel! They’re both amazing creatures, but judging them on “superiority” is like giving points for breathing underwater versus climbing trees. They’re both fantastic at what they do, but in totally different ways.

Differing evolutionary paths create diversity, not superiority.

Here’s why the “superiority game” doesn’t work:

  • Different strengths: Every living thing has its own unique set of skills. A jellyfish might not win a braininess award, but it can sting you – that’s a pretty cool trick!
  • Survival of the different: Nature isn’t about who’s the smartest or strongest, it’s about who can survive and reproduce. A moss clinging to a rock might seem boring, but it’s been around for millions of years – that’s pretty darn successful!
  • Beneficial webs: Living things are all connected. The “gross” worms in your garden help break down leaves, making nutrients for plants. Even the pesky mosquito has a role (though a debatable one!) in the food chain.

So, instead of looking for a winner, let’s celebrate the incredible diversity of life on Earth! It’s like a giant, mind-blowing party with all sorts of amazing guests.

As the Dust Settles
Featured

As the Dust Settles

When Questions About an “Emergency” Rise from Paper to Air

The way the wind cuts across the river this time of year. The way older buildings hold heat but never quite hold air. I told myself that was why my chest felt tight again on certain mornings. Age, perhaps.

Discover more from Roosevelt Island, New York, Daily News

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading